After a close look and some careful consideration: Not me, that’s who. I’m far more interested in OpenMoko and more impressed by Nokia’s N95.
The iPhone had a lot of potential, and certainly had its share of hype; but what’s it all about? It certainly is pretty. I’l give them that much; but it more reminds me of an expensive rice racer. It makes a lot of noise, looks pretty and being built from a Honda Civic will allow for an acceptable lifespan…just don’t look under the hood. The iPhone seems to be missing some critical components and really isn’t all that innovative for a consumer device costing upwards of $750 (if you can find one). To top it off, Apple has made the phone exclusively available to AT&T customers (You may remember them as the company that collaborated with the NSA to illegally wiretap and data mine American’s communications) and it is shackled with limitations on applications and DRM.
The iPhone enables the user to play videos and audio, has a nice web browser and a few functional applications. How is that any different than my 2+ year old Treo 650 or the even older Treo 600? Over the past year or so, I’ve watched more television on my phone while waiting in life’s ubiquitous queues than I have at home. Thanks to TCPMP I’ve been able to keep up on The Daily Show, BSG and even knocked down a few movies. I also have a very nice SSH client, web browser, email, camera (still and video), IRC, IM, and MP3 player. I can also do things like record phone calls, blog and find my way around town. I suppose there is the much touted WiFi capability, which is a nice feature. I wish I had it on my 650 for use around town when I’m in range of the Tempe Muni WiFi, or out in S.F. but I consider it secondary to the data communication provided by my carrier. On the iPhone it is the old EDGE technology, which is even slower than the now ancient 1xRTT data network from Sprint. Seems to me that Apple and AT&T are riding the hype-tsunami right into the breakers; when they will announce an upgraded version with GPS and 3G data stream. (Did I mention it doesn’t come with GPS?) I’m guessing this will occur just in time for the Christmas rush…and I’m a betting man. Any takers?
Compare this with the N95 from Nokia, a truly advanced phone for the US market. Check out the list of features on this baby:
- Cellular Bands: HSDPA / GSM 850 / 900 / 1800 / 1900
- Data Networks: GPRS, HSCSD, EDGE, 3G and 802.11 b/g WiFi
- 5 Megapixel camera with flash
- 480p 30fps Video (That’s nearly DVD quality folks)
- Built-in GPS navigation (Over 100 country maps included AND you can use Google maps as well!)
- Not only plays standard format multi-media, but also plays unencrypted AAC and WMA
- Standad 3.5 mm audio jack (2.5mm jacks are annoying)
- TV Out (What? TV OUT on a phone???)
- FM Radio receiver
- Industry standard USB interface (None of that $50 proprietary cable crap!)
It also has your standard smartphone applications like “office document viewer”, organizer, etc…Ah yes, but it doesn’t do that nifty scrolly album jacket thing when looking at my iTunes acquired DRM-shackled media. Damn.
I for one am excited for the release of the entirely open source OpenMoko phone due out on the 9th of July. The goal of the project is of course a free and open mobile phone operating system. The long term goal being “…phone software won’t be tied to a phone. You can install any OpenMoko software over the whole range of phones, and if you upgrade your phone, you don’t lose the software.”
That is an exciting idea to me.
To add fuel to the fire, it looks as though they now have serious, committed corporate sponsorship ala Ubuntu (see Canonical) from First International Computer (You may know them from all those years of building your own PCs…Mobo’s anyone?) FIC has backed the project and they now officially are part of the FIC Group.
They will be putting up two models to start. Developer and Hacker editions of the Neo 1973 (GTA01B_v4). Yes, they are inviting us to pick apart, develop and generally hack on their phone. Everything but the carrier GSM protocol stack is open source and fair game. The commercial version will ship sometime in October. Like the N95 and unlike the iPhone, it will have both WiFi as well as G3 connectivity…and even better: it will be completely open source.